TREC License #6291 PI · Veteran-Owned · Serving San Antonio since 2002 Call (210) 255-3134
Rod InspectsSan Antonio Home Inspections (210) 255-3134

Home Inspector vs. Appraiser: Understanding Their Roles

The short answer

A home inspector evaluates the condition of a house for the buyer, while an appraiser estimates the home's market value, usually for the buyer's lender. In Texas the buyer chooses and hires the inspector during the option period, and the lender orders the appraisal as part of the loan. Rod Inspects, a San Antonio home inspection company with TREC License #6291 PI, has inspected homes since 2002.

A circuit breaker panel with color-coded wiring

What Does a Home Inspector Do?

A home inspector looks at how the house is built and how it is working right now. On inspection day the inspector walks the roof, goes into the attic, opens the electrical panel, runs the plumbing fixtures, operates the heating and cooling, and checks the foundation, walls, windows, doors and built-in appliances. In Texas that work follows the Standards of Practice set by the Texas Real Estate Commission, and the findings go into a written report.

The question a home inspection answers is: what is the condition of this house, and what will need attention? It is written for you, the buyer, so you can negotiate repairs, plan for maintenance or walk away. You can see the full scope on our what's inspected page.

What Does a Home Appraiser Do?

An appraiser estimates what the home is worth on the open market. The appraiser looks at the size, layout, age, overall condition and features of the house, then compares it with similar homes that have sold nearby. The result is a value opinion in a written appraisal report.

The question an appraisal answers is: is this house worth what the lender is about to lend against it? That's why the lender orders it. Appraisers in Texas are licensed by the Texas Appraiser Licensing and Certification Board, a different agency from the one that licenses home inspectors.

An appraiser may note obvious problems that affect value, but an appraisal is not a room-by-room test of the home's systems.

What Are the Key Differences Between a Home Inspector and an Appraiser?

Home inspectorAppraiser
Main questionWhat condition is the house in?What is the house worth?
Works forYou, the buyerUsually the lender
Who orders itYouThe lender
What they testRoof, structure, electrical, plumbing, HVAC, attic and moreSize, features, overall condition and comparable sales
Licensed byTRECTALCB
What you getA condition report you can act onA value opinion

The short version: the appraisal protects the loan, and the inspection protects you. A home can appraise right at the contract price and still need a new roof, a panel replacement or foundation work. Rod Inspects also uses infrared thermal technology to identify temperature patterns that may indicate hidden moisture or missing insulation, something an appraisal is never designed to find. Read more about infrared thermal inspections.

Who Hires and Pays for Each One in Texas?

You hire the home inspector. You choose the company, book the time and receive the report, and the inspector's duty is to you. That is why it matters to choose an inspector who is independent and explains things plainly. Rod Inspects has three licensed inspectors on the team and works only for its clients.

The lender orders the appraisal, even though the appraisal fee is usually charged to the buyer as part of the loan costs. Your loan officer can tell you exactly how that works on your loan. Because the lender is the client for the appraisal, you may receive a copy, but it was not written to answer your questions about the house.

When Do the Inspection and the Appraisal Happen During a San Antonio Purchase?

The inspection comes first. Most Texas contracts include an option period, a set number of days when the buyer can inspect and decide whether to move forward. Searching "home inspection near me San Antonio" the day your contract is signed is the right instinct, because every day you wait is a day less to act on the report.

The appraisal usually happens later, after your loan application is underway, and it runs on the lender's schedule. A typical order looks like this:

  1. Contract signed and option period begins
  2. Buyer's home inspection, with a written report with photographs
  3. Repair requests or renegotiation, if needed, before the option period ends
  4. Appraisal ordered by the lender
  5. Final loan approval and closing

Your agent and loan officer can confirm the dates in your own contract.

Does a VA or FHA Appraisal Replace a Home Inspection?

No. San Antonio is Military City USA, and plenty of buyers here use VA loans. A VA appraisal checks the home against the VA's Minimum Property Requirements, which look for basic livability and obvious hazards. That check is useful, but it is not a home inspection, and it does not test the systems the way an inspector does.

FHA loans work the same way. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development tells FHA borrowers in writing that an FHA appraisal is not a home inspection, and encourages them to get one. You can read HUD's guidance for buyers at HUD.gov.

Rod Stewardson is a U.S. Navy veteran, and we know how fast a PCS move can go. If you're buying from out of state, the photo report lets you see what we found even if you can't be there.

What Happens If the Inspection and the Appraisal Disagree?

They are not really measuring the same thing, so they rarely contradict each other. More often they tell different parts of one story:

  • The appraisal comes in at value, but the inspection finds major repairs. Use the report and contractor estimates to ask the seller for repairs or a credit during your option period.
  • The appraisal comes in low. That is a financing question for your agent and loan officer, not something the inspection changes.
  • The appraiser flags a condition the lender wants fixed. Your inspection report usually gives more detail on the same item, which helps you and the seller sort out the repair.

Keep both reports together in your closing file. The appraisal tells you how the market saw the house on one day. The inspection report stays useful for years, because it is a map of where the shutoffs are, how old the major systems are and which maintenance items to plan for. If you're still early in the process, our home inspection checklist walks you through what to do before, during and after inspection day, so nothing slips between the two appointments.

Who Is Rod Inspects?

Rod Inspects is a San Antonio, Texas home inspection company led by Rod Stewardson, who holds TREC License #6291 PI. The business has been inspecting homes since 2002 and has 300+ five-star Google reviews. Its three licensed inspectors, Rod Stewardson, Derek Saari and Tyler Stewardson, provide buyer, seller, new construction, builder's warranty, infrared thermal and pool and irrigation inspections in San Antonio, New Braunfels, Schertz, Cibolo, Seguin, San Marcos, McQueeney, Hollywood Park and Alamo Heights. Every inspection is. Start with our San Antonio home inspection page or the Rod Inspects homepage.

Asphalt shingles being nailed onto a sloped roof
FAQ

What Do Buyers Ask About Inspectors and Appraisers?

What is the difference between a home inspection and an appraisal?

A home inspection reports the condition of the house for the buyer. An appraisal estimates the market value of the house, usually for the buyer's lender.

Do I need a home inspection if I already have an appraisal?

Yes. An appraisal is not designed to test the roof, structure, electrical, plumbing or heating and cooling systems, so it can miss problems that a home inspection is built to find.

Does a VA appraisal count as a home inspection?

No. A VA appraisal checks the home against the VA's Minimum Property Requirements and estimates value. It does not replace a full home inspection of the home's systems.

Which comes first, the home inspection or the appraisal?

In most Texas purchases the home inspection comes first, during the option period. The lender orders the appraisal later as part of the loan process.

Who does the home inspector work for?

The home inspector works for the client who hires them, which is usually the buyer. The appraiser usually works for the lender.

Ready to Find Out What the Appraisal Can't Tell You?

Book your buyer's inspection as soon as your contract is signed. Schedule online or call Rod Inspects.

Call (210) 255-3134 Schedule Now